Not so keen on Keane

Roy Keane, the player, the manager, the assistant manager and all round head case. With his new book out, extracts are been banded around the internet so much, you probably won’t need to purchase it.

The words read and seen discussed the most online are of course the Celtic related ones. Yes, yes, he’s had more interesting times in his career, but as a Celtic fan, you tend to take more of an interest in the comments that hit closer to home.

In his book he talks about turning down the Celtic managers job as well as making references to his short spell playing for the club under Gordon Strachan. Strachan didn’t come in for any abuse but he was singled out by Keane for something not far off.

Personally, I was never really a fan of Roy Keane coming to Celtic. It was an unnecessary move for the club but Dermot Desmond obviously wanted him no matter how long or short that would have been for.

An Irish International basket case in a Celtic jersey. Every Celtic supporters dream right? No.

First off, when he declared he wanted to finish his career at Celtic all I could marvel at was the arrogance. That Celtic Football Club was some kind of retirement home for ageing footballers.

Celtic were doing just fine that season if memory serves correct. Sure, Keane came in and twisted the knife a little more to compound further misery on our now extinct rivals.

That may have been worth it alone for some. If he had played another season I might have given him some respect.

Keane said he was on £15K whilst others were saying it was more. Personally I don’t really care how much it was because what annoyed me more about it was that Dermot Desmond was prepared to sanction that kind of money when it suited him and not when it was badly needed as we have seen over the years.

In the years that followed, Celtic made a similar move by bringing in Robbie Keane. By that point the league was pretty much over for Celtic but still, the club sanctioned a loan move for Robbie Keane when things were grim.

To be fair to Robbie, he did his job by scoring goals. His goals to game ratio was just under one for every game but it didn’t change the fate of Celtic that season or indeed the fate of Tony Mowbray.

Perhaps it was a throw of the dice by Dermot, perhaps it was just to boost shirt sales and put bums on seats. I would probably argue that it was more of a need then, than when Roy Keane joined.

The book itself has more in store than just Celtic stories. Indeed some of the juicier stuff is from his days at Manchester United but it gets my back up when screw-balls like Roy Keane feel they just have to vent their spleen about Celtic.

As a person he will always tell it how it is. As a pundit he has been no different.

I don’t dislike the guy, but sometimes he just needs to shut his noise. He was a great player, not right in the head and controversial pretty much all of the time, but every now again he reminds me of why I never wanted him at Celtic Park as a player or a manager.

Hail! Hail!



Well, well, well

Wouldn’t you know it? No sooner has David Moyes sworn in at Man United than Neil Lennon is top of the list to replace him at Everton.

Now I don’t know about you but I can’t see this post being of interest to Lennon. Not at this point in his career anyway.

Everton are a good club but they’ve achieved little in modern times. Sure, they’ve remained stable in a highly competitive league but for a decade Moyes has been the glue that’s held Everton them in that position.

Tight budgets are the norm for Everton these days. While this may be something that Lennon also has experience of, he is used to playing Europe now.

Perhaps this kind of role could lure Lennon in a few years time. In reality though, Lennon has much left to do at Celtic and he still is young so the opportunities are there for him in the future.

League titles, domestic trophies and Champions League are all a reality at Celtic Park. At Everton its about Premier League survival.

Hail! Hail!


End of an era

When a giant figure leaves the scene forever, a new era is born. Now that Sir Alex Ferguson has announced his retirement, that time is now.

The news of his departure has engulfed the world of sport since the media broke the story. Ferguson did of course mention retirement around a decade ago, but nothing ever transpired until now.

At the ripe old age of 71, Ferguson is a legend of the game. His length of service and influence at Manchester United has gained respect around the football world and beyond.

In terms of the best managers in the world, particularly in Scotland and England, he is up there with the best. Many debate who is/was the best but at the end of the day it is a personal choice.

Firstly you have to have managed one of the few clubs who possess a certain bond with their fans and that club must also have a kind of ‘romance’ about it. Most of all though, you have to have made your mark in the world of football and taken the best prize of all – the European Cup.

Ferguson has done this and follows in the footsteps of those who he admired most in the game. They don’t make mangers like this any more, we live in a different age, particularly in the UK.

Money dominates the game these days and the game is now a business. The modern day supporter is a shadow of those who crammed into the terraces of yesteryear.

Galla signings, advertising, merchandise, TV rights and coverage are now staple in the game. Ferguson has witnessed these changes in his decades within football.

His legacy is that even in the modern day he taught a fair few opponents a lesson. More importantly he has gained their respect and influenced their own careers.

The gap that Ferguson leaves is not only going to be a hard hole to fill at Old Trafford. The experience he retires with leaves chasm in the game.

Its been said that David Moyes is Ferguson’s imminent replacement at Manchester United. There is no doubt that the former Celtic player and Preston manager is a respected figure in the Premier League, but is he the choice every United fan wants?

Moyes has been in charge at Everton for eleven years. He arrived at the end of the 2001-2002 season and finished 15th in the league.

In the four seasons that followed he would alternate between a top half and bottom half of the Premier League. For the next six season he would keep Everton in the top half of the table and in the current season he is set to do the same.

He has survived in the Premier League all this time on a tight budget which is to be admired. His experience of survival is perhaps sometimes overlooked due to fact he has won nothing with Everton.

If his appointment does eventually transpire as it is expected to today, many will see this as a ‘safe’ appointment. People will also call into question what that will bring to a club like Manchester United whose fans expect success at home and abroad.

When you thrust money into the hands of a good coach, which Moyes quite clearly is, you begin to wonder what the result might be. Good or bad this is an appointment that may not be everyone’s cup of tea.

Although Moyes has been the front runner in the media for this vacancy, Jose Mourinho has been on the lips of many. The only reservation I would think that United have about Mourinho would be that it wouldn’t be about the club, but about himself.

That does not fit in with a club like United. It is a fans club and community but he remains an admirer of Ferguson and United.

Mourinho has always had money to spend. At United, he would be unlikely to get the financial freedom he is used to.

Moyes’ stability in the Premier League stands him in good stead. Any money he does get at United, will be more than he has been used to at Everton.

If he is indeed the man who is announced later today as the new United manager, then he obviously has the approval of Ferguson. Nobody in the UK knows the game more than he.

It’s fair to say he has lived and breathed the game, battled with the best and worn his heart on his sleeve. Having never been a United supporter, I have grown to respect Ferguson as a football man.

If he passes the torch of success to Moyes without the sort of sticky start that he had when he came to Manchester United, it will be a good beginning. The rest though…has yet to be written.

Hail! Hail!