Brendan conned us all…

He came to Celtic telling stories of his love for the club. A supporter man and boy who was privileged to work with the late Tommy Burns.

The “dream job”, as he put it, was also a dream appointment for all of the fans. We were all in – hook, line and sinker.

And how could we question his adoration after delivering an invincible treble in his first season? Simultaneously putting us back on the Champions League stage.

In season two he delivered an unprecedented double treble with slightly better progress in Europe. The football wasn’t as good as the first season, but we were jubilant with back-to-back trebles nonetheless.

Then last summer matters hit the skids and the wheels came off. Players leaving, players wanting to leave, players not coming in.

Internal struggles with the board and/or Peter Lawwell appeared to be at the heart of the breakdown. Numerous comments to the media by Rodgers seemed to cast a shadow over the club.

The summer of discontent began with the departure of Stuart Armstrong (an unsurprising exit), failure to land John McGinn (a long expected signing), wantaway rebel Dedryck Boyata (a disruptive farce) and eleventh hour departure of Moussa Dembele (a knife in the back). And who can forget about that lucrative Chinese offer Brendan had to tell us about after he’d turned it down?

The fractures from last summer never fully healed. Initially we all levelled blame at the board, but after Rodgers’ sharp exit I’m re-evaluating that.

As a Liverpool fan in the family advised me last summer, Brendan had a bit of an ego problem. I wasn’t entirely certain then but I am now.

Even the comments of Dembele make for good reading now. Might there be more to last summer’s breakdown than we realise?

For Rodgers to walk out at such a crucial stage in the season is unforgivable. It’s clear he wanted out, but could have retained his credibility and stayed until the end of the season.

What’s disappointing is that he’s settled for a mid-table club who’ll probably win nothing whilst he’s there. Leicester City won the league for the first time in their history three years ago, but don’t expect that to ever happen again in our lifetime.

He’s their third manager since they sacked Ranieri two years ago. He might be the right fit for Leicester now, but for how long?

Brendan has conned the supporters and players to jump ship at the first sight of Premier League land. I’ve held him in high regard since his days at Swansea, but now that is all undone.

I can’t take away what he’s achieved. It’s astonishing.

To walk away from Celtic whilst on the brink of history though, I cannot begin to fathom. It’s clear he never had the affection he claimed to have for Celtic.

No true Celtic fan walks away from the club in this manner. You just wouldn’t.

It’s career suicide. Especially to a club like Leicester City, who are 11 points from the relegation zone.

I’d love to wish him all the best, but I can’t. He betrayed us with his hollow words.

Obviously he’ll have the cash to spend at Leicester that Celtic didn’t. He won’t enjoy European football though, domestic silverware or the legendary status he had in Glasgow.

He’s actually lost all respect amongst the Celtic fans now. In years to come it will be interesting to reflect upon this and see how it rests in Celtic history.

Brendan’s followed the money for sure, but Leicester won’t replicate the success of three years ago. That ship has sailed.

In the interim, Celtic have installed former interim and permanent manager Neil Lennon. It’s an ideal short term fix which will hopefully keep the momentum going.

Alongside him will be John Kennedy as assistant and Damien Duff as his number three. Tonight they’ll all be at Tynecastle, but who will be in the dugout has yet to be confirmed.

The task of preserving Celtic’s eight point lead at the top of the league is the priority. The team will be prepared by John Kennedy.

There’s obviously more at stake this season with a treble in sight. The disruptive nature of Rodgers’ exit though could be just the invitation other Scottish clubs needed to halt Celtic’s domination.

The hard work for Lennon, Kennedy and Duff begins this evening. Let’s hope they can see it through to the summer.

Hail! Hail!

Stevie Mac

Advertisements

At least the weather will be nice in Valencia…

What a see saw of a week it’s been for Celtic. The highs and lows of football.

Having started 2019 in impeccably blistering domestic form, Valencia came to Celtic Park for the first leg of the last 32 tie of the Europa League. There was confidence amongst the support that Celtic could get a result.

The reality of European football can put all of your domestic achievements in perspective rather quickly. And despite starting and finishing the game somewhat strong, Valencia all but put Celtic’s European hopes to bed with two goals.

Brendan remained buoyant that Celtic could still bounce back but the likelihood of that is slim to none. Our away record in Europe does not make for good reading so this would indeed be a masterstroke or stroke of luck if the odds were beaten.

As it is, the odds of beating Valencia at Celtic Park were already stacked against us. Admittedly, we did shoot ourselves in the foot (again) and when things were clearly not working on the park we failed to change it in a timely manner (again).

Next up was a late afternoon meeting in Kilmarnock last Sunday. Steve Clarke’s side have given us problems in the past and the media were already piling the pressure on Celtic as to whether they would have a European hangover.

I mean, as if this story hasn’t been used countless times already. Yes, it is more likely that after facing a European side that Celtic may not be at their best for the next domestic opponent.

That’s because the opponents are generally way above the standard of anything else Scotland can produce (other than Celtic), long distance travel is often involved and usually the domestic side we are facing hasn’t had European football to contend with. So it’s a kind of no brainer that Celtic might suffer after over-exerting themselves midweek.

By comparison, European football had a similar effect on our friends over at Ibrox. In eleven European games played, both teams had similar post-European results.

Celtic         W7 D1 L3
Rangers      W7 D2 L2

This isn’t some new phenomena. It is a likely risk which few in Scottish football experience.

In the Scottish Premiership, three out of four of Celtic’s defeats and one out of their three draws followed European football. Europe has had the greatest impact on the club’s league position.

The one remaining defeat and two draws have occurred outside of this scenario though. These results followed an international break, the League Cup final and a midweek seven goal thriller away to in Aberdeen.

Again, is it likely to drop points or lose a game following a major event? Of course it is, but to suggest Celtic suffer from a hangover when no other team does is quite frankly laughable, particularly when Celtic are generally the only team from Scotland to have been flying the flag in Europe regularly.

When Celtic took to the field against Kilmarnock last Sunday, it did look like it was heading for a draw. However, Celtic didn’t give up and Scott Brown was credited with scoring the match winner and a second yellow card.

It was a silly yellow card, but I saw it coming. The question I would like to know is would he still have been booked if the fans hadn’t run onto the grass?

That was Broony’s second goal of the season. It was also back-to-back domestic goals for the club captain.

The last time he managed that was in May 2015 against Dundee and Aberdeen. That new contract has certainly refocused his Celtic career, having not scored almost two years to the day of his last goal for the club in February 2017.

I’d like to see him put in a good performance this evening in Valencia. We all know this game is a dead rubber, but the players can at least show us some spirit because the fans deserve it, especially the travelling ones.

The last 32 will be the terminus for Celtic’s European adventures once again. This is and will continue to be our stop until we approach these games correctly.

Buying more expensive players isn’t necessarily the answer or within our means as a club. Getting it right first time against organised opponents is.

Setting out your stall correctly, cutting out mistakes and deploying the right tactics is a good start. Valencia’s starting eleven had a market value of over £140M with nearly £60M on the bench.

In hindsight there’s a lot Brendan and the Bhoys could have done to play better and get a result without having to match them financially. Money isn’t always the answer though. it’s just a measure of the market a team like Valencia operate in.

Our team will require further surgery in the summer. Our coaching team also have much to work out if any progress is to be made in Europe at all.

Indeed the question some might already be asking is can Brendan take us any further in Europe? We have our limitations, but has this European tour gone as far as it can?

I actually think we can do better. A lot better.

Tonight though we will close the door on the European stage until July’s qualifiers come around again. Then it’s game on as we turn out attention to a treble-treble.

Hail! Hail!

Stevie Mac

Can Celtic actually beat Valencia?

On Thursday night Celtic return to the European arena. Valencia are in Glasgow for the first leg of the last 32 Europa League encounter with the Scottish Champions.

There was jubilation among Celtic fans to make this stage in Europe for the second season running. Having exited the Champions League in qualification, the Europa League was a consolation for all Celtic fans.

Celtic beat Suduva in the final qualifier to reach the group phase of the Europa League. There they were paired with Salzburg, Leipzig and familiar foes, Rosenborg.

The group stage opened at home with a 1-0 win over the Norwegian champions, but that was followed up by two straight defeats away to Salzburg (3-1) and Leipzig (2-0). Having suffered back-to-back defeats there was a huge sense of disappointment, but with two home games and one away game remaining, there remained a slender chance that Celtic could still secure second spot.

Celtic beat Leipzig 2-1 in Glasgow and beat Rosenborg 0-1 in Trondheim. Going into the final group stage match, Celtic only had to avoid defeat against the Austrian Champions.

Salzburg had already won the group and there was a hope that they might not be as ruthless in Glasgow. As it turned out they were in command for most of the game and beat Celtic on what was beginning to look like a miserable end to an up and down campaign.

Meanwhile over in Germany, Leipzig were winning 1-0 and all was looking good for them. Then Tore Reginiussen nodded home an equaliser in the 86th minute for Rosenborg, throwing Celtic a lifeline.

Fans erupted in unison at Celtic Park and behind TV screens at home and in the pubs as the news filtered through. Both ties continued to the 96th (Leipzig) and 98th (Glasgow) minute as we held our breathes.

Even an Olivier Ntcham goal from a rebounded penalty in the dying moments did little to settle the nerves. A strange night of disappointment and joy it was.

A lot was made of Celtic’s progression at the last moment. When things like that happen so late on you can understand people teams being disappointed – we’ve been there.

This wasn’t about just one game though. The group stage is about six games and how well your team do over that period.

Celtic won three and lost three. Leipzig won two, drew one and lost three.

It doesn’t matter which end of the fixture list you got your results. Just who does better overall and that was Salzburg and Celtic.

So now Celtic face another tough opponent. Salzburg were by far the best side in our group and Valencia will be no less of a challenge.

The La Liga club finished third in their Champions League group behind Juventus and Manchester United and parachuted into this round as Celtic did last year. Our work is cut out for us.

If you face an opponent that spent over £100M last summer you know this will be no easy tie. Thankfully, Celtic have recruited in January, particularly in the attacking areas.

To say we were lightweight up front during our European campaign would be an understatement. The late exit by Moussa Dembele and rotating absences of Leigh Griffiths and Odsonne Edouard did little to help our chances.

Now Celtic have more options up front even though they had to leave one of their four new players out of the UEFA squad. The rules only permit three changes and with Vakoun Bayo behind the rest in terms of preparation it made sense to leave him out.

What Celtic must hope for is having as many players as possible fit and ready for these games against Valencia. The last time the Spaniards visited Celtic Park it was a home win.

The tie went to penalties as Valencia had won the first leg 1-0 in Spain. The La Liga club progressed as Celtic lost 5-4 on spot kicks in Glasgow.

There’s no doubt that since that match in December 2001 the gulf between both clubs has increased. It is the nature of the football climate, particularly where wealth is concerned.

The odds are stacked against Celtic. They have never progressed from the last 32 of this competition whilst Valencia have never been defeated.

For Celtic, it will be a case of third time lucky. As for Valencia, they will be looking to continue in the dance m same vein.

In realistic terms, European football is a battlefield that Celtic struggle on. The club have lost ground through a combination self-inflicted wounds and a rapidly growing financial gap between the elite and the rest of European football.

There is also a factor of blame on the whole of Scottish football. Poor investment, lack of competition and abysmal horizon scanning by the people who govern our game means that we have failed to keep up.

Scotland has been overtaken by nations who at one time were way behind us. We are now way behind those countries.

Brendan Rodgers’ hasn’t had the best of European campaigns with Celtic. He began his European journey in 2016 with Celtic by losing to Gibraltarian side Lincoln Red Imps 1-0 which would be overturned in the home leg.

Tough qualifiers against Astana and Hapoel Be’er Sheva followed, but Celtic made the Champions League. It was a tough group with Manchester City, Barcelona and Borussia Monchengladbach.

Brendan presided over Celtic’s biggest ever European defeat at the hands of Barcelona when they lost 7-0 in the Camp Nou. The same season he managed two very credible draws against Manchester City but Celtic fell flat on their face after failing to win a single match and only managing three draws over all.

His second attempt at Europe was much harder. After another three grueling rounds of qualifiers, Celtic were dropped into the group of death.

PSG, Bayern Munich and Anderlecht offered Celtic a tough challenge. Despite losing five of their six games Celtic qualified for the last 32 of the Europa League by winning one match.

It came down to a head-to-head with Anderlecht. Celtic won 0-3 in Belgium, Anderlecht won 0-1 in Scotland putting Celtic through despite losing the game on matchday six to the Belgian club.

It was progress in its leanest form as Celtic remained in Europe beyond Christmas. There they faced Zenit St Petersburg and got off to a good start with a 1-0 win in Glasgow.

However, it was a different story in Russia as Roberto Mancini’s side wiped the floor with Celtic. 0-3 in Russia was the end of Celtic’s European adventure.

Which brings us roundly to this season. What can Celtic do to change their fortunes this time?

Is it possible for Brendan to get a result against a team sitting 8th in La Liga? 8th in that league is better than first in many leagues including our own.

This is Brendan’s third season at Celtic. The club is still in Europe by whichever means.

Under Martin O’Neill in his third season at Celtic, the club went all the way to the UEFA Cup Final, the trophy’s former title. Is it at all likely that Brendan can overcome greater odds and do what Martin did in this third term?

I doubt many people would give us a chance and yet it often takes this amount of time to build something. Occasionally, such things can occur out of disappointment or misfortune.

Am I confident that Celtic can beat a team of Valencia’s stature? No, not unless we cut out mistakes and deploy the right team.

When I think back to 2003, I never thought Celtic would overcome Blackburn Rovers, Celta Vigo, Stuttgart, Liverpool and Boavista. None of those matches were foregone conclusions and yet Celtic had solid team.

What I do feel more confident about are our player options. Timo Weah, Oliver Burke and Jeremy Toljan have all come in and looked superb.

These positions are now looking stronger. We still have injuries to manage, but we have a better chance at these ties now than we did pre-recruitment.

What remains to be done are deploying the right tactics. Brendan has shot himself in the foot in Europe on several occasions, but he also knows how to change things.

This is a real test for the players and the coaching team. The challenge is huge and we must have realistic expectations but they have the full backing of the fans as ever.

All we can do is support them in the stands and behind the TV screens. The rest is up to Brendan and the Bhoys.

Hail! Hail!

Stevie Mac

Positive window for Celtic as they look toward more domestic success

So Celtic stored up all their good news until transfer deadline day. With many rumours over the last few weeks, the club followed up their early January activity with further deals announced on the final day of the transfer window.

Maryan Shved, Andrew Gutman and Manny Perez (I already like him for his name) have all signed permanent deals, but have gone back out on loan until the summer. Another incoming loan deal was secured as Jeremy Toljan was drafted in from Borussia Dortmund until the summer.

He hasn’t played first team football this season, having only appeared on the bench twice for the Bundesliga side. However, Celtic needed backup at left and right back and he can play both.

It would seem though that he is unlikely to be at Celtic beyond the summer so he is not a long term replacement. I don’t see him displacing Mikael Lustig either.

Brendan has stuck by the Swede even when he’s had awful performances. So much so, he hasn’t even replaced him with Cristian Gamboa or Anthony Ralston unless absolutely necessary.

It’ll be interesting to see how much game time Toljan actually gets and in which position. With Emilio Izaguirre the only fit left back, he may even play there.

Earlier in the week, Celtic had announced that youngster Ewan Henderson had penned a new deal. The younger brother of former Celt, Liam, will hope to force himself into a busy midfield.

Speaking of midfielders signing new deals, Scott Brown put an end to speculation in his future by signing on for another two years. It’s likely to be his final professional contract at Celtic.

By the time hia contract expires he’ll be a month from turning 36 years old. That could mean a player-coach/coaching role at Celtic or somewhere else.

Many felt it was time for Broony to move on, but he is such a huge character on the field, in the dressing room and among the support. The club will not find it easy to find a player with those qualities.

Celtic moved a couple of existing players out on loan until the summer as well. Lewis Morgan joined up with his former manager Jack Ross at League One side Sunderland.

The youngster needs game time badly and I thought he’d get a chance this season. Though he’s managed just one starting eleven place in thirteen appearances.

Competition is fierce in the midfield and Youssouf Mulumbu has also found himself out on loan. Having made two starts in three appearances he is back at former club Kilmarnock until the summer as Steve Clarke side aims to get the club’s highest league finish since the 1960’s.

Also down Ayrshire way is Calvin Miller. After spending the first half of the season on loan at Dundee, he will now be looking to add to his sixteen games and one goal achieved in Tayside by making an impact at Ayr United.

Not going anywhere is former Dundee defender, Jack Hendry. He looked all set for a loan spell having not imposed himself in the Celtic defence since he joined in January 2018.

With injuries to Filip Benkovic and Dedryck Boyata, Brendan is a bit short of options at centre half. Kris Ajer and Jozo Simunovic are his current best choice, but if one gets crocked he’ll need Hendry.

In a strange twist of fate, this could be a good opportunity for the 23 year old. Many fans don’t think he’s good enough so perhaps he’ll get the chance to prove them wrong.

Scott Allan will remain at the club until the summer as well. Despite having signed a pre-contract with Hibs, it was rumoured they tried to bring him in early, but for one reason or another a deal was not struck so he’ll do what he’s done for most of his Celtic career and watch from the sidelines.

I had hoped Celtic would offload Marvin Compper, but he’s still lurking around somewhere. I don’t even know if he still trains with the first team, but he may yet be of some assistance by helping hus fellow German settle in.

Toljan was a youth player at Hoffenheim when Compper was playing in the first team. Compper would later move to Fiorentina with Toljan moving into the first team six months later.

So perhaps there is a role for Compper after all. Just maybe not on the park.

All in all this has been a positive window for Celtic. The squad has been freshened up to keep the green flag flying high.

Next up is Celtic’s first away game of the year. St Johnstone entertain the Hoops at McDiarmid Park for the lunchtime league tie this Sunday.

Brendan Rodgers can expect another stubborn performance from Tommy Wright’s team. Some tweaking was required during Wednesday night’s encounter with the Saints to get the eventual 2-0 win at Celtic Park.

The Perthshire side will feel more comfortable at home, but Celtic will want to maintain their winning streak of 2019. With new faces to bed in and players coming back into contention it is a competitive time within the squad.

That can only be good news for Brendan. Role on Sunday.

Hail! Hail!

Stevie Mac