Celtic Surgery – Burke the first of many?

Having lost their final game of 2018 in such deplorable style, the January transfer window could not have arrived at a better time for Celtic. The challenge this season has been more realistic than any other in recent years because there has actually been one.

Many have dismissed the suggestion of a title race, some have said it is of Celtic’s own making. Both of those statements have their own degree of validity.

We’ve always been happy to use the phrase “title race” when you know you have two or more genuine challengers. Celtic and Rangers were always in the title race by default, but since the 1872 club’s demise, it has really just been about Celtic.

Even when Ronny Deila took charge, the title was pretty much always going to be Celtic’s. Aberdeen made some headway to interrupt that, but Celtic always came through.

This season has been a somewhat different story because Celtic had a shambolic summer transfer window, some want away rebels in the dressing room, a manager making statements to the press which had many of us wondering if he was still happy at the club and of course exiting the Champions League. What followed was a poor start to the domestic campaign which had only begun improve as we got nearer the end of the year.

Now you can agree with those that think this is of Celtic’s own making yet these are the kind of factors that can affect a title race. When Rangers 1872 were going for ten-in-a-row, their team was ageing and certain individuals were set to leave at the end of that season, including their manager.

Some of that, I would argue, helped Celtic win the title that season. Yes, we had drafted in some better talent and were looking good, but it went down to the wire.

I don’t agree with Archie Knox’s sentiments that Celtic are about to do the same as Rangers did in 1998. We have it within our means to ensure it doesn’t happen – they didnt’.

Rangers 2012, for all their faults, have put together a team who are playing as consistent as any other club in the top flight. We can pick holes in their stats just as we can in any other club in the Scottish Premiership, but the fact is they are where they are on merit just like Kilmarnock, Aberdeen, Hearts etc.

It doesn’t matter how a title race happens, you simply have one based upon the circumstances that occur. Celtic have struggled this season and the signs were already apparent last season.

Yet despite all of that, the club weren’t proactive enough. This season we have a smaller squad hindered further by absentees and the poor form of key players.

Celtic still have a game at hand and currently sit in 1st place with the same points as Rangers, but with a slightly better goal difference. At the same stage last season, Celtic were nine points ahead of Aberdeen (2nd) and eleven points ahead of Rangers (3rd).

That was pretty much how last season ended too with Aberdeen finishing nine points behind in 2nd place and that gap on 3rd placed Rangers widening slightly to twelve points. So how can you not say it is a title race this season?

Isn’t that what we want anyway? Celtic may have dropped the ball, but it doesn’t change the fact teams are breathing down our neck.

And there is more than just Rangers to think about. Everything but the kitchen sink is being thrown at Celtic right now in order to halt their domination.

Be it any of the other top six teams, match officials or dirty tricks on and off the park, Celtic have to show why they are Champions. And by doing that Brendan will have to reassemble his troops, get some backing from the board and come out fighting after the winter break.

The threat is real and Celtic have not strengthened from a position of strength. Not for the first time in our history either.

It has been reassuring that many of our key players have signed new deals this year but the fact is Brendan Rodgers has recycled this team about as much as he can. We need new blood now.

Today, the club have drafted in Oliver Burke on loan from West Brom. Other attacking players have been targeted, but this one is curious.

Burke is only 21 years old, capped five times as a full Scottish international and now made his fifth professional club move, this being his second loan spell. Having started out at Nottingham Forrest and a brief loan period at Bradford, he caught the eye of up-and-coming RB Leipzig who paid a lot of money for him.

After a year in the Bundesliga, West Brom decided to pay even more money for his services. He hasn’t played a lot of football this season so this will be a chance for him to prove himself.

His preferred role is as a right-winger, but he can also play on the left and as a forward. I’m guessing that it is his physicality that is of interest to Brendan Rodgers.

At 6 ft 2 inches he is not small so I wouldn’t be surprised if the manager plans to use him as a forward. I’m sure he’ll be a welcome addition to the team for the remainder of the season.

There will be further signatures in this window in the attacking department by the sounds of it, but Celtic must sort out their defence. They currently have twelve first team defenders, five of which are out of contract in the summer.

Of the seven that remain, one will never be seen in the first team again (Marvin Compper), one is out on loan currently and not a defender in my opinion (Calvin Miller) and one has taken on the Gary Gillespie role (Jozo Simunovic). That leaves the Brat Pack of Anthony Ralston, Jack Hendry, Kris Ajer and Kieran Tierney.

Now the latter four could end up forging a long-term partnership in the Celtic defence, but we lack depth and experience in this area right now. It is a huge area of concern for us, particularly in Europe.

Our midfield is actually not doing too badly so long as it is set up correctly. We lost this battle at Ibrox with the best set up not being utilised.

I don’t expect any midfielders to come in during this window, but I do expect defensive improvement as well as in attack. Let’s hope Oliver Burke is the first of many faces in January.

Hail! Hail!

Stevie Mac

7 thoughts on “Celtic Surgery – Burke the first of many?

  1. 2 years ago our manager explained how he’s come to learn that the January transfer window was the most important window, as it gives new players 6 months of working with us to settle and bed in for the July cup finals that are the champions league qualifiers

    How does a 6 month loan deal help the manager!?

    Have we fallen so far in such a short space of time we’ve no ability to forward plan?

    Have we just sent a message out to say the level of ambition is winning the league championship contest, that we have been responsible for creating in the first place ?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Fair points mate, but we need to see where we are at when this window closes , if we have failed to strengthen subdtantially we will be in a dogfight for the title imo. Wherr the fault would lie for that is another story


  2. At this meeting with Fleming and the Sfa the Club must confirm if your officials will not protect our players will protect themselves even if we end up with 6 men and an Abandoned game no longer will we be endangered by rotten officials next game we can kick stamp and punch Morelos as it’s not foul play


  3. We’ve needed a RB for at least a season and a half, we’ve needed a backup LB since Izzy left, the best we could do was to bring Izzy back to the club. Someone at the club is clearly not doing their job properly. Obvious weaklinks are not being targeted, bringing Burke in for 4-5 months with no option to buy certainly shouldn’t have been anywhere near the top of our shopping list.


    • Yes ,clearly there are stand out requiremnets but the addition of burke surely gives us a decent option wide left. He may not have been top of the shopping list just because he has been first in?


  4. Miller isn’t on loan any more. He’s back. Jack Hendry will probably be loaned and cannot be in the first team this season if we hope to win anything else. Ralston it’s getting a run now, but we need an experienced right back for key games and to bed in for Europe next season. Those 4 might become the first team defence in future, but just now only one of them can be considered for the biggest games.


  5. Pingback: Celtic Surgery – Burke the first of many? | CELTS FROM THE SOUTH | The Celtic Footsoldiers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.