The departure of Teemu Pukki to Brøndby IF for less than £500k should be a lesson learned for Celtic. For a forward with a fairly unimpressive record, the club have taken a hit on this player.
The Finnish international signed a four year contract in 2013 for a fee in the region of £2M-£3M. He scored on his début away to Hearts and then again on his home début and you can’t really ask for more than that from a new player.
However, things never really progressed for Pukki from those early days. Chances would go a miss, he fell out of the picture and the void left by Gary Hooper was never filled.
In fact if it wasn’t for the goal scoring prowess of Kris Commons, Celtic would have been well short of fire power that season. Celtic were still without a proven goalscorer.
What Pukki’s role was supposed to be when he was brought in I am uncertain of. He wasn’t exactly prolific at any of his previous clubs and Celtic were clearly in need of a striker hence the arrival of Leigh Griffiths in January 2014.
Despite all of this, I stuck by Pukki hoping that the scouting team had seen something to convince them to pluck him from FC Schalke 04 in the first place. The club have unearthed some gems in recent years but we’ve also seen some donkeys at the same time.
Amido Baldé, Mohamed Bangura and Derk Boerrigter are recent examples of such poor buys. Whilst Boerrigter had a good spell in his career, he had become prone to injury and as for the other two, they didn’t even come with a proven track record.
A couple of million pounds may not seem like a lot in the modern day when you consider Celtic were spending that kind of money in the mid 90’s. It’s still a waste of money though particularly when these guys have failed to produce the goods.
That has been a set back for Celtic because if you buy one player to do a job and wait another year to find out if he’s good enough or not, then you’ve lost some ground. Then you have the arduous task of trying to move that player on to recoup some of the money shelled out on fees and wages.
You can’t expect all signings to work out because there are a plethora of factors that can affect a player at a club. Some or most of these can be out of the club’s control but at the very least the player should have some solid statistics to back up your willingness to spend a few million quid on them.
Gary Hooper is an example of a good signing. He had a good goalscoring record in a competitive league and was worth every penny.
If Celtic are planning to purchase forwards in this price bracket again, I’d suggest that they come with a track record as Hooper did. Pukki, Bangura and Baldé did not come with that kind of background but each cost around the same.
They have been abject failures for Celtic Football Club. Both financially and on the field of play.
At least in the case of Stefan Šćepović, he was doing a job in Spain before setting foot on Scottish soil. There’s still a chance for him you might think but he has yet to kick-start his Celtic career.
Whoever is on the radar for Celtic this summer, we will want to see any money spent, spent well. I’d rather the club paid £1M for a young Scottish player or give one of their own youth players a chance than blow it on some journeyman with a poor CV.
Let’s see what the summer brings.